Are you feeling the pain of Third-Party Paper?

Reviewing draft contracts from the other party in the negotiation (so called ‘third-party paper) is like playing away in sport – home advantage counts.

June 26, 2023

Reviewing draft contracts from the other party in the negotiation (so called ‘third-party paper) is like playing away in sport – home advantage counts. Between  55-60% of American Football and around 65% of English Premier League matches are won by the host. In contracting, the playing away disadvantage is strong enough for 25% of General Counsel to cite “too much third-party paper” as one of their top three headaches in a 2020 survey.

The big picture is that all top executives want their departments to digitise and become data powered. Third-party paper creates a massive barrier to this. The solution is process improvement aligned with technology.

Why the pain?

Own-terms contracts are structured data which has a profound impact at each stage of the contract lifecycle. Contracts can be created at a press of a button after completing a short questionnaire. Business teams can ‘self serve’, often producing the draft contract and entirely negotiating it using playbooks. Everything is geared to the processes of the home team. Data flows seamlessly into contract lifecycle management (CLM) systems, in turn meaning easier post-signing contract management.

The opposite is true of third-party paper. They are a jumble of words rather than a structured database. A simple concept like warranty period has thousands, if not millions, of variations. They are mostly settled through email tennis exchanges and difficult to put into an efficient process. Contracts are often held-up in Legal. Data extraction and capture is either missed or done manually. Contract management is time consuming. There are big staff wellbeing issues created around repetitive contract review. In a nutshell – a nightmare.

Can’t we just insist on our own terms? Great if you are always the biggest gorilla in the forest. But if not, or business circumstances dictate otherwise, you’ll be dealing with some third-party paper.

5 pain relief remedies

1. Internal processes:

Even with the technology available, reviewing and negotiating contracts is largely manual and heavily reliant on humans. The processes and tools must be fit for purpose. Contract triage is critical. Contracts should come in a single front door, pre-screened for value and risk and sent down different rails. Low-value contracts can be handled by business managers, others by specialist contract managers and higher value ones involving Legal.  Have clear templates for review output –issues lists for example. Use the dashboards, workflows and other tools in your existing CLM or matter management system. Finally, have a process which helps the data transfer later on.   

2. Dealing with the other side:

Have a template workflow that you agree with the other side which sets out the process up to signing. This should include any platforms or technology which will be involved. Leverage your counterparty’s technology and process – if they have a smart contracting platform, such as Juro or Avvoka, with documents in a web browser and negotiation functions, use it – it’s free! Set a timetable and regular calls if necessary. Identify any schedules that need to come from the reviewing party. Agree an order sheet or brief term sheet. Set expectations. Send a sheet of must haves or red flags in advance of the contract. Delay the drafting until these are agreed in principle. Don’t redline and trade drafts (until the last draft). Send a clear issues list, agree conceptually and record this. Simple stuff, but contract parties often overlook the huge time saving that can be reaped by having simple but effective processes between the parties.     

3. Playbooks are essential:

How often do you hear the comment “we don’t have time to set-up playbooks”. This doesn’t need to be so. Get your business and legal teams in a meeting for two hours and write on post-it notes (ideally digital ones) the key clauses and concepts and the usual sticking points, normal fall-back positions and outcomes (using the 80:20 rule – focus on the 80% of issues that can be addressed in 20% of the time). This is your first draft playbook. Review, adjust and expand it regularly. Finally, playbooks are even better if digital (see ‘Use technology wisely’ below). 

4. Use technology wisely:

Until now, technology played a limited role in reviewing and extracting data from third-party papers. Now, it is becoming central to (i) negotiation and (ii) contract data management.

Over-hyped AI is not helping. The natural language processing (NLP) technology in most CLM systems can do a deviation analysis from a common starting point. This is fine for own terms but not for third-party paper which comes in many shapes and sizes. So, most users don’t bother using these features. Similarly AI technology that automatically amends third-party paper is fine for simple contracts but struggles beyond this. 

We should be using technology more effectively. 

This could start with simple rule-based technology driving a triage system. Users manually input data and the contracts are prioritised and sent to the right place. Some simple AI technology could then be introduced to automate fully the triage, without need for data input by humans. Use triage as a way of building confidence in the AI – which will improve over time.  

Beyond that, the more powerful NLP systems, such as Tiro’s  from Lexical Labs, have a combination of cutting edge AI, a logic based expert system and a digital contract playbook.

Tiro has an NLP and machine learning engine that learns to understand key concepts in a contract. So like other systems, it can, for example, identify and extract an IP indemnity in whatever form it exists in a third-party paper. Tiro’s logic-based expert system is then able to analyse those concepts in very granular detail. For example, understanding who gives the indemnity, what it covers, whether it is capped and what it excludes.    

This core technology sits at the heart of a digital contract playbook.The user can review third-party papers against their playbook rules, see red flags or amber warnings and get smart summaries of key issues. They can then access fall back wording, amend the drafts and create reports and issues lists.

In a nutshell, start simply, empower – not replace - humans, and embed digital contract playbooks.

5. Capture, transfer and analyse data:

Currently this is being done manually. Technology should digitise third-party paper and capture relevant contract data and metadata and transfer it into enterprise software. The technology must be fit for purpose. 

For example, a manufacturing company may include contract risk scoring on an overall risk and reward evaluation of its customers using manual data input into its own software. The contract risk scoring can be automatically fed into the software.

Similarly, by feeding this data automatically (not manually) into CLM systems, their post signing contract management features can be fully utilised. This means the true potential of the CLM system and its return on investment can be realised.  

The longer term objective is for Corporate Legal and Contract Managers to become ‘data powered’. Technology will play a huge role, particularly in turning unstructured data in third-party paper into actionable insights.

The technology will evolve so that users can ask questions of the contracts and receive instant responses. What is the contract term? When is my next report due? Is there any automatic renewal and when?  Which contracts have ‘change in control’ provisions?

Beyond these basic contract management tasks, users can move into advanced analytics which leverage strategic value from their contract portfolio. What cross-selling opportunities exist between divisions in a company? What correlation exists between the terms of my contracts and my profits?

The end game

In 10-20 years, the concept of ‘third-party’ paper may disappear altogether. Industry bodies may standardise to such an extent that the difference between playing ‘home’ and ‘away’ becomes marginal.

For now, we need to deal with the pain of third-party paper by good processes and taking small steps, one yard at a time, with technology. In time, they will lead to a home run.

No items found.
Looking for some more value?

Other Posts

Browse some related whitepapers

Initial views on Recent Developments at OpenAI

OpenAi’s recent Developer Day and the launch of GPT-4 Turbo, the new Assistants API and the ability to create custom versions of ChatGPT for specific purposes (GPTs) presents the contracting industry with both a massive opportunity and a potential bombshell.
Read more

Automated Contract intake and triage

Automating your contract intake and triage might be the most valuable legal operations change you make in the next year. Here's why:
Read more

Tendering - Pass the Parcel - Who's in charge of the contract?

Revamp your tendering process, mitigate risks, and secure winning deals by harnessing AI contract review technology.
Read more

Why procurement contracting often seems harder than sales - but shouldn’t be!

When it comes to negotiating a contract for buying goods or services, the seller has it easy!
Read more

Why contract playbooks are essential (and easier than ever to set-up)

Unleash the Power of Contract Playbooks: Discover the essential steps to create and optimise playbooks for streamlined contract negotiation, improved outcomes, and significant time and cost savings in less than 3 hours.
Read more

Structured data in contracts and open AI algorithms

Explore the future of contracts with structured data and open AI algorithms, driving efficiency, risk management, and innovation in the legal industry.
Read more

Reimagining Law - The automated M&A deal?

Redesigning M&A deals with cutting-edge technology and streamlined processes, empowering companies to reshape the future of legal transactions.
Read more

How Fast Growing Digital Businesses can Harness the Power of AI Contract Review

Unlock the Power of AI Contract Review for Fast-Growing Digital Businesses and Streamline Your Contracting Process with Efficiency and Precision
Read more

Lexical Labs automatically risk scores your contracts

Tiro, from Lexical Labs, is the most advanced AI based automated contract review system available. Tiro reviews contracts - using both deep learning and logic based algorithms - just like a lawyer or specialist contract reviewer would.
Read more

Contract triage and pre-screening using Automated Contract Review

Unleash the power of Automated Contract Review (ACR) technologies and revolutionize your contract triage process, saving time, reducing costs, and empowering your business teams for faster and more efficient contract management.
Read more

A Contract Management Blueprint for Agile Businesses

How do you keep up with the contract workload that comes with a rapidly scaling agile business? This guide explores how to develop a best-in-class contract management function.
Read more

Automated review of Customer Contracts – Stantec Case Study

Experience faster contract reviews, improved risk outcomes, and enhanced efficiency with Tiro, the AI-powered automated contract review software - Stantec's case study reveals groundbreaking results.
Read more

7 questions to ask your AI contract review vendor

Unlocking the Potential: Discover the 7 Essential Questions to Ask Your AI Contract Review Vendor and Gain Insight into the Future of Contract Management.
Read more

7 Trends Transforming Contracting and Legal Professionals in the Engineering, Construction and Advanced Manufacturing Sectors

Discover the remarkable transformation taking place in engineering, construction, and advanced manufacturing sectors as contracting and legal professionals embrace innovation and adapt to the demands of the future.
Read more

An AI Engineer’s Personal Journey Into Law

Discover the striking parallels between the worlds of law and software engineering as an AI engineer embarks on a personal journey, unraveling the hidden connections and potential for automation in contract review and negotiation.
Read more

Sign up for our newsletter

No spam, we promise! Just the occasional email with product updates and value from our whitepapers.

By clicking Sign Up you're confirming that you agree with our Terms of Service.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.