Why contract playbooks are essential (and easier than ever to set-up)

Unleash the Power of Contract Playbooks: Discover the essential steps to create and optimise playbooks for streamlined contract negotiation, improved outcomes, and significant time and cost savings in less than 3 hours.

June 22, 2023


Contract playbooks are now more important and easier to create than ever but are unfortunately still underused. While critics express doubts about their use and overall effectiveness over the perceived time investment and their alleged inflexibility, the availability of better contract data and analytics and the technology to digitise playbooks are heralding an exciting time for the playbook. 

We set out below the key ingredients of an effective playbook and our guide to setting up a playbook in less than 3 hours.  

The benefits: time and money saved; better outcomes; demonstrated business value added by the legal team.

What is a contract playbook?

Contract playbooks come in different shapes and sizes, but broadly it is a guide that:

  • Identifies the key points that are repeatedly negotiated in a contract and providing ideal and fall-back positions on those points
  • Gives clear explanations to juniors or business colleagues on the desired outcomes and their importance 
  • Sets out any escalation points that need sign-off by seniors or other departments
  • Gives appropriate contract wording to achieve the desired outcome
  • Often contains the workflow and process around contract finalisation 

What are the benefits?

The benefits include time saved training colleagues and reviewing contracts, better business outcomes, more consistency and a framework that allows for constant review of risk and business objectives across a contract portfolio. It provides a benchmark that can adapt to real world conditions over time. 

Contract review can also be flexibly deployed between internal legal, contract managers, business managers and external providers - meaning better and cheaper resourcing with the same outcomes. 

Why are they underused?

While this sounds fine in theory, the devil is in the detail and playbooks aren’t universally popular. Mainly, the perceived upfront time investment, lack of flexibility and the tendency to over complicate puts people off. Some playbooks run to 20-30 pages in quite a dense format, as seen in the image below. There is often a misconception that they need to capture all or nearly all of the negotiation points and provide hard and fast rules. This needn’t be the case. Indeed, one of the most satisfying aspects of negotiating contracts is the exercise of common sense and judgment. 

4 key ingredients for an effective playbook

  1. Customer and result orientated: Playbooks should aim to provide better business outcomes and a better customer experience in contract negotiation. Good playbooks address this by properly assessing and balancing the needs and interests of all stakeholders - the functions such as sales, procurement, risk, compliance and legal but also the people involved.

    A short workshop involving all those stakeholders is a great way to kick off a playbook. Regular workshops and feedback sessions keep the playbook relevant. 

    Playbooks should promote process improvement. This might mean delegating contract review to more junior legal staff or outside providers, allowing business teams to ‘self serve’ on contracts or introducing contract automation technology. Depending on the objective, the form and content will be very different.  
  1. Simple and effective design: Pareto’s principle (allowing 80% of the outcomes to be achieved by focusing on 20% of the inputs) is a great basis for a playbook. Perfection does not need to be the enemy of the good. As shown below, a simple but effective playbook can be generated in a few hours. 

    Simple design techniques can further enhance its effectiveness and impact on the audience. Think visual diagrams and creative ways of explaining legal outcomes.  
  1. Effective use of data: A playbook should focus on business outcomes and address the trade-off that exists between the time and money expended in a negotiation and the desired outcome. Data is vital in informing the best negotiation approach. 

    For example, a playbook often provides rules for agreeing a sensible cap on liability under a contract. If this ignores practice in the market for similar contracts, the time expended negotiating that position or securing internal approvals for exceptions, the playbook can quickly defeat its own objectives.

    The workshops mentioned above are a great source of both anecdotal and empirical data. Technology can provide further help.  
  1. Smart use of technology: Technology is unlocking the true potential for playbooks in different ways.

    First, it's a great source of data analysis. For example, NLP based contract review systems can easily answer the fundamental question: “what have we negotiated in the past?” Before the development of this technology, it took days to answer. The advent of machine readable contracts will accelerate this trend.   Furthermore, greater sharing of contract data with technology platforms, as recently pioneered in LawTech UK’s Pilot Sandbox (https://technation.io/lawtechsandboxpilot/), will enable businesses to understand properly what is a ‘standard market position’ or provide easy access to common contract wording. Technology platforms also provide data around negotiation times and bottlenecks.

    Second, contract assembly technologies can directly link to playbooks. Business teams can therefore generate playbook compliant contracts by completing a simple questionnaire. Fallback positions can also be stored in those systems.

    Third, the playbook can itself be digitised on a technology platform that contains both NLP and playbook technology. The technology will automatically review a draft contract or a redline against the playbook, highlight problematic provisions and provide solutions in the form of suggested mark-up wording or comments or guidance. The system will automate a report of the draft contract against the playbook and capture the data for contract management purposes. 

    Digitised playbooks are easy to set-up and are dynamic. They can capture and analyse data and can be constantly adapted and improved. For example, knowhow such as new drafting can be tagged and shared by users. Guidance notes can be given by video. The current ‘live’ contract portfolio can be analysed against the playbook position - a much more important data point than assessing one particular contract.   

Simple steps for playbook creation and continuous improvement

  1. Gather initial written materials such as a small sample of contracts, guides and preferred wording (if exists). Identify contracts to be covered by the playbook.
  2. Hold a 2 hour workshop with key business, legal and risk stakeholders - use an interactive whiteboard and/or post-it notes so each participant specifies their top 6-8 key (i) objectives (ii) most important provisions and (iii) most problematic / negotiated provisions. Use the 80:20 rule and agree 6-10 key items for the playbook. In the workshop - agree preferred position, acceptable fallback position and any escalation points. Write-up the playbook in the workshop - don’t leave till later. Don’t aim for perfection as it will change and improve periodically. 
  3. (Optional) - Use NLP or similar technology to benchmark your current contract portfolio against the playbook. If the current portfolio is significantly misaligned, consider changing the playbook at the first review.
  4. (Optional) - Set-up your playbook in the contract assembly or contract review technology that you are using or have chosen to use.
  5. Use the playbook for 3-4 months then hold a first review meeting with the same team. If you have the technology and data available, score your recent contracts against the playbook and collect data on negotiation times and bottlenecks. Assess that data and anecdotal data from team members in the meeting and make changes to preferred positions, fallback positions and escalation triggers. 
  6. Periodically review and improve the playbook every 3-4 months.  
No items found.
Looking for some more value?

Other Posts

Browse some related whitepapers

Initial views on Recent Developments at OpenAI

OpenAi’s recent Developer Day and the launch of GPT-4 Turbo, the new Assistants API and the ability to create custom versions of ChatGPT for specific purposes (GPTs) presents the contracting industry with both a massive opportunity and a potential bombshell.
Read more

Automated Contract intake and triage

Automating your contract intake and triage might be the most valuable legal operations change you make in the next year. Here's why:
Read more

Tendering - Pass the Parcel - Who's in charge of the contract?

Revamp your tendering process, mitigate risks, and secure winning deals by harnessing AI contract review technology.
Read more

Why procurement contracting often seems harder than sales - but shouldn’t be!

When it comes to negotiating a contract for buying goods or services, the seller has it easy!
Read more

Structured data in contracts and open AI algorithms

Explore the future of contracts with structured data and open AI algorithms, driving efficiency, risk management, and innovation in the legal industry.
Read more

Reimagining Law - The automated M&A deal?

Redesigning M&A deals with cutting-edge technology and streamlined processes, empowering companies to reshape the future of legal transactions.
Read more

How Fast Growing Digital Businesses can Harness the Power of AI Contract Review

Unlock the Power of AI Contract Review for Fast-Growing Digital Businesses and Streamline Your Contracting Process with Efficiency and Precision
Read more

Lexical Labs automatically risk scores your contracts

Tiro, from Lexical Labs, is the most advanced AI based automated contract review system available. Tiro reviews contracts - using both deep learning and logic based algorithms - just like a lawyer or specialist contract reviewer would.
Read more

Contract triage and pre-screening using Automated Contract Review

Unleash the power of Automated Contract Review (ACR) technologies and revolutionize your contract triage process, saving time, reducing costs, and empowering your business teams for faster and more efficient contract management.
Read more

A Contract Management Blueprint for Agile Businesses

How do you keep up with the contract workload that comes with a rapidly scaling agile business? This guide explores how to develop a best-in-class contract management function.
Read more

Automated review of Customer Contracts – Stantec Case Study

Experience faster contract reviews, improved risk outcomes, and enhanced efficiency with Tiro, the AI-powered automated contract review software - Stantec's case study reveals groundbreaking results.
Read more

7 questions to ask your AI contract review vendor

Unlocking the Potential: Discover the 7 Essential Questions to Ask Your AI Contract Review Vendor and Gain Insight into the Future of Contract Management.
Read more

7 Trends Transforming Contracting and Legal Professionals in the Engineering, Construction and Advanced Manufacturing Sectors

Discover the remarkable transformation taking place in engineering, construction, and advanced manufacturing sectors as contracting and legal professionals embrace innovation and adapt to the demands of the future.
Read more

An AI Engineer’s Personal Journey Into Law

Discover the striking parallels between the worlds of law and software engineering as an AI engineer embarks on a personal journey, unraveling the hidden connections and potential for automation in contract review and negotiation.
Read more

Are you feeling the pain of Third-Party Paper?

Reviewing draft contracts from the other party in the negotiation (so called ‘third-party paper) is like playing away in sport – home advantage counts.
Read more

Sign up for our newsletter

No spam, we promise! Just the occasional email with product updates and value from our whitepapers.

By clicking Sign Up you're confirming that you agree with our Terms of Service.
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.